Corporate Visions

Challenging Customers Reduces Effectiveness of Renewal Messaging, Study Finds

A study highlighted on Corporate Visions reveals that customers who challenge renewal messaging significantly diminish its effectiveness, impacting growth priorities such as customer retention and sales performance.

Skip to content

Growth Programs

Your Growth Priorities

Pick the priority you need to fix first and get a clear starting point.

Acquire More Customers

Expand & Retain Customers

Create Winnable Pipeline

Improve Win Rates

Protect Your Profit Margins

Measure & Manage Performance

Evolve Your Sales Methodology

Targeted Solutions

Solutions and such do some things and some other things here Maecenas sed diam eget risus varius blandit sit amet non magna. Aenean lacinia bibendum nulla.

Precision Skills\ \ Assessments

Sales \ \ Training

Messaging

Leadership &\ \ Coaching

Buyer \ \ Insights

Solutions\ \ Overview

Not Sure Where to Start?

Learn more about our targeted solutions and see what fits the gap you’re seeing.

Explore Solutions

Who We Serve

Overview

You’re measured on different outcomes—but your success depends on the same buyer decisions. This is where you find the programs and proof built for your goals.

Choose your role to see what that looks like in practice.

Explore by Role

Role-Based Solutions

Find the solutions that map to your responsibilities—and the outcomes you’re expected to deliver.

Sales \ \ Enablement

Sales \ \ Leaders

Product\ \ Marketing

Account\ \ Management

Executive\ \ Leaders

Roles\ \ Overview

Case Studies

See how revenue teams like yours use buyer evidence to win more—and keep more.

View Case Studies

Approach

Why Corporate Visions

Our Research Methodology

Sales Competency Framework

Just-in-Time Enablement

Community

Emblaze Community

Get perspective—and pressure-test your plans with peers.

Upcoming Events

Emblaze Resources

Stop guessing. Get the research and tools members actually use.

Explore Resources

Research

Podcast

Pressure-Test Your Strategies

and Fine-Tune Your Approaches

Get the Evidence to Build Stronger Teams

Rethink how you drive growth. Bring your toughest questions. Leave with clearer decisions.

Join Now

Emblaze Members Login

Resources

Overview

When teams rely on opinions, content gets noisy and inconsistent. Our resources are grounded in buyer evidence—so you can sharpen decisions, messaging, and execution.

Find insights, articles, webinars, and more evidence-backed resources to grow revenue.

Browse the Resource Library

Events

Case Studies

Books

Search

SIGN IN

Talk to Us

NEWS

Challenging Customers Reduces Effectiveness of Renewal Messaging, Study Finds

November 1, 2016

New research reveals provocative messaging at “renewal time” makes customers more willing to shop around and even switch providers

PLEASANTON, Calif., Nov. 1, 2016 — Corporate Visions, Inc., the leading marketing and sales messaging, content and skills training company, announced the results of an experiment showing that provocative messaging approaches can put you at a significant disadvantage in a renewal selling context, and actually increase customers’ willingness to shop around and even switch to an alternative. For the experiment, Corporate Visions contracted with Dr. Zakary Tormala, an expert in persuasion and messaging who conducted the study. Separately, Tormala is a social psychologist at the Stanford Graduate School of Business.

The study, which tested two provocative selling messages against a message that reinforced the known causes of status quo bias, found that participants in the provocative conditions were 10 percent more likely to switch providers or shop around than participants in the status quo reinforcement message. “At a time when challenging the customer is all the rage, this research stands as a strong rebuttal to the idea that provocative messaging is universally applicable,” said Tim Riesterer, chief strategy officer of Corporate Visions. “As this study shows, marketing messaging that challenges the status quo can actually backfire in a renewal selling scenario, putting you at a significant disadvantage when you’re trying to protect your status as the incumbent.” The study also found that participants who experienced the status quo reinforcement message, which documented success, reported a:

  • 13 percent boost in intentions to renew, relative to the two provocative messages.
  • 9 percent boost in positive attitudes, compared to the two provocative messages.
  • 7 percent lift in credibility perceptions, relative to the provocative conditions.

“There’s a time and a place for a disruptive message that injects urgency into the conversation, and it’s when you’re the outsider looking to defeat the status quo or introduce a new concept, not when you’re the insider trying to maintain a service or subscription,” Riesterer said. “So many customer conversations revolve around the question of ‘Why Stay,’ and to answer that question effectively, marketers and salespeople need to be great at reinforcing the causes of the status quo bias in their messaging, content and skills.” For more information, please check out the research brief.

Recent News

October 1, 2026

An 18-month study of 119 new inside-sales hires finds that sellers who combine AI practice with experienced-seller observation perform best on both execution and adaptability.

September 22, 2026

Jarod Greene, experienced go-to-market leader and Gartner alum, joins Corporate Visions to lead its marketing organization.

August 20, 2026

Study of more than 4,000 B2B sales pursuits finds sellers who default to one approach win less often and give up more margin than those who adapt strategy deal by deal.

Explore More News